Shias, you say you don’t have an authentic book other than the Quran?
Posted Friday, March 6, 2009 by admin
We’ll just skip the part where you say it’s been twisted or there are hidden chapters etc.
Anyway, you regard al kafi to be a good book after the Quran right?
Yes, I know you’re going to say it’s not 100% authentic.
My question is how do you differentiate between weak and strong hadiths?
“Allaah often lies and does mistakes.”
(USOOL-E-KAAFI, page #328, yaqoob kulaini, vol 1).
Why would the person who ‘compiled’ these ‘hadiths’ even put that in his book? It’s no brainer. Even if you belive it’s weak, why would the compiler put it in his book?
That book degrades Allah (even if you believe it’s weak, it’s still there) Don’t you question your books over such tremendous grave errors regarding Allah?
Are you going to take the easy way out and blame us ‘wahabis’ of lying and adding things in your books?
Why was that in the book?
Leon, thanks for clarifying that…NOT.
SUCH A MAJOR MISTAKE !! in the book YET NO SHIA SCHOLAR CALLED THE BOOK WEAK !
IT IS ONLY THESE INTERNET SHIA THAT WILL CALL IT WEAK !
Ah yes, Wahabi vs. Shi’a. Always refreshing to see opposing sects argue about which version of Islam is the best. Elitism at it’s finest.
Did you know that Al-Kafi has 18000 traditions? Did you know that out of 18000 only 5,800 are to be considered as Sahih (Authentic)? Unfortunately, those who fights the shias are quoting hadiths the one shias reject them. When you said how do we know hadith is unauthentic, we say, we take the hadith and scale with Qur’an, once we see the Qur’an rejects the hadith, then we throw it away, this how the shias judge the hadith
Yes! thats the easy way out.
al Kafi doesnt reference his books like the way u have it, u did not even get that from a reliable shia site, dont lie, u got it from a Nasabi fitna loving site
answer my questions next time and dont dodge them, and listen to ur own advice, worry about urself and ur books, dont trash my questions next time
1. we don’t lable any book as “sahih” except the Holy Quran
2. we do not believe the Holy Quran is croupted
3.
“Imam Raza [as] stated: When you find two contradictory reports about same matter then present both of them before the Quran since it contains instruction of every Halal and Haram [matter]. Therefore whichever is in accordance to the Quran adhere to it while present the one before Sunnah of Prophet [s] which is not present in Quran”
Ayoon Akhbar Raza, Volume 2 page 20 by Sheikh Saduq